Tuesday, March 13, 2012

What REAL Medical, Scientific and Clinical Experts Have to Say About Colloidal Silver Usage

So-called “skeptics” and “quack busters” groups claim colloidal silver usage is little more than “quackery” and “snake oil” being promulgated by “charlatans.”

Often, these groups use well-known medical or science personalities to spread anti-colloidal silver propaganda throughout the popular media. In other cases, they apparently work together to manipulate Google’s internet search engine results so that only negative articles about natural health topics such as colloidal silver appear at the top of the results.

But in spite of the negative propaganda against colloidal silver, many bona-fide doctors, clinical researchers and scientists have actually studied the science behind colloidal silver, and have even used colloidal silver and other silver-based substances in their practices. And as a result, they know for a fact that silver’s infection-fighting qualities are beyond dispute.

In this article we’ll take a look at what some of the most prominent medical, science and clinical research experts in the world today have to say about colloidal silver and its usage. And in the process we’ll see why the so-called “skeptics” and “quack busters” are all-too-often truly the real charlatans…

Hi, Steve Barwick here, for www.TheSilverEdge.com...

In a previous issue, I wrote about Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, who in a recent article in the Montreal Gazette has publicly decried colloidal silver usage as “quackery”…and who stated in that article, in no unequivocal terms, that colloidal silver simply doesn’t work in the human body. In his own words:

“[Colloidal silver] may well have an antibacterial effect in a petri dish, but that is a long way from having an antibacterial effect when taken internally. No scientific evidence supports the benefit of ingesting any form of colloidal silver.”

I also wrote about some of the interesting people and organizations with which Dr. Joe Schwarcz is infamously associated, including Lorne Trottier, who sits on the board of the notorious atheistic and anti-natural health “skeptics” group, CFI Canada…

…and who, according to the Montreal Gazette, has contributed $5.5 million dollars to the efforts of Dr. Schwarcz to put natural health remedies and their proponents “out of business.”

Yes, folks. It’s true.

So called “skeptics” groups and “quack buster” organizations are quite literally spending millions upon millions of dollars to make sure that the only opinion the public can form of natural healing and nutritional substances like colloidal silver is a decidedly negative one.

In this article, however, you’ll discover what some of the real medical, science and clinical research experts have to say about the many documented, infection-fighting benefits of colloidal silver and other silver-based remedies.

And you’ll see why natural health “skeptics” like Dr. Joe Schwarcz of Canada are dead wrong in their negative assertions against colloidal silver usage.

The Experts Disagree With Canada’s "Mr. Science"!

So let’s get started. Here’s an interesting quote from Dr. Kent Holtorf, M.D., of the Holtorf Medical Group, from his medical White Paper, “Safety and Efficacy of Intravenous Oligodynamic Silver”:

"Hundreds of thousands of doses of oral colloidal silver and thousands of doses of intravenous colloidal silver are given every month in the United States.

This is usually done to treat acute and chronic infections including those associated with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and fibromyalgia (FM).

The effectiveness of the use of oral and intravenous colloidal silver in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia was presented at the 38th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Environmental Medicine…

…(Identifying the Causes and Exploring the Newest Treatment Options for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, Fibromyalgia and Environmental Sensitivities) in October 2003…

The extremely low level of colloidal silver used at 23 parts per million (ppm) has been shown to have little or no potential for toxicity while having the significant potential for clinical benefit.

The effectiveness of oligodynamic silver’s antimicrobial action at extremely low doses in combination with its potential immune stimulating actions, makes oligodynamic silver an ideal naturally occurring substance in the treatment of CFS and FM."

-- Dr. Kent Holtorf, M.D., Holtorf Medical Group, "Safety and Efficacy of Intravenous Oligodynamic Silver"

So, according to Dr. Holtorf -- a bona-fide and highly respected M.D. -- not only is colloidal silver effective in the treatment of chronic fatigue syndrome and fibromyalgia, it’s effective at such low levels there’s “little or no potential for toxicity.”

In other words, it’s about as safe as you can get. Hmmm. This Dr. Holtorf must be some kind of quack, right? Well, no. He’s actually the founder and medical director of Holtorf Medical Group, which specializes in innovative evidence-based therapies for hard-to-treat and poorly understood illnesses such as…

….hypothyroidism, complex endocrine dysfunction, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia and chronic infectious diseases including Lyme disease and chronic viral illness. What’s more, he’s published a number of peer-reviewed endocrine reviews, and is a guest editor/peer-reviewer for a number of medical journals including the journal Endocrine.

He received his doctorate of medicine from St. Louis University, with residency training at UCLA. He’s also the Endocrinology Expert for AOL Health. And he’s regularly featured as a medical expert in major magazines and on TV news, including Fox News and others.

So this must be some kind of anomaly, right? A bona-fide medical doctor who touts colloidal silver usage? Surely there aren’t any other bona-fide medical doctors who advocate for the use of colloidal silver.


Here’s another interesting quote on colloidal silver usage, this one from Dr. Jonathan Wright, M.D., a graduate of Harvard, as well as the University of Michigan Medical School, and who now runs the famous Tahoma Clinic in Washington state:

"Colloidal silver just might be the next germ-fighting wonder drug. And not just for the serious threats making headlines: It's also effective against bacterial infections like strep throat, viruses like the flu, and fungal infections like Candida.

No matter how much a germ mutates, it can't change enough to escape the damaging effects of colloidal silver. And in the process, the silver doesn't harm human tissue or kill off the good bacteria in the intestine the way antibiotics and other medications do…

…Beginning in the 1970s, several independent researchers found that silver ions easily destroy Candida and other fungi. But it wasn't until a pilot study during the mid- 1990s that included human patients suffering from terminal AIDS that medical researchers established solid evidence showing just how quick and effective silver ions can be in the treatment of Candida as well as HIV.

In this study, nine individuals who were near death were divided into two subgroups. One group suffered from HIV and a terrible Candida infection. The other group suffered from both HIV and an extreme form of malnutrition (known as Wasting Syndrome).

The researchers found that in both groups the colloidal silver was capable of killing pathogens and purging the bloodstream of germ defenses in order to restore the immune system."

-- Dr. Jonathan Wright, MD, Tahoma Clinic, WA

Do you think Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, should have balanced out his anti-colloidal silver diatribe by quoting the views of someone like Dr. Jonathan Wright, M.D…a bona-fide medical doctor and Harvard graduate, who actually knows the medical science behind the use of colloidal silver, and who’s actually used colloidal silver in his clinical practice, and has personally witnessed its effectiveness first-hand?

Ahhh...I guess that's just too much to ask for. After all, I think we all know that fairness and balance is not even remotely a part of the equation when it comes to the propaganda efforts of "skeptics" and "quack busters."

Here’s another interesting quote on colloidal silver from a high-powered medical expert, Dr. Joseph Weissman, M.D., a board certified immunologist and Assistant Clinical Professor at the University of California Medical School:

"Today, many antibiotics are losing the battle with germs. Fortunately, the best germ killer, which was discovered over 2,000 years ago, is finally getting the proper attention from medical science - natural silver. I sincerely recommend that everyone have electrically generated colloidal silver in their home as an antiseptic, antibacterial and antifungal agent."

-- Dr. Joseph Weissman, M.D. board certified immunologist and Assistant Clinical Professor at the University of California Medical School

I wonder if Dr. Weissman realizes how much trouble he could be in with the so-called "quack busters" and "skeptics," for holding the view that the entire general public should "have electrically generated silver in their home" for "antiseptic, antibacterial and antifungal purposes"?

Well, truth be told, I don't think Dr. Weissman is too darned worried about their self-serving views. Do you?

Okay…that’s strike three for the quack busters and their ilk. Should I keep going? Ahh… why not? We’ll give them another chance or two. Here’s a quote from the Toxic Metals Research Program of the prestigious Dartmouth University. Surely they’ll agree with Canada’s “Mr. Science,” and decry silver as being horrifically unsafe and unfit for the human body. Let’s see:

"Trace amounts of silver are in the bodies of all humans and animals. We normally take in between 70 and 88 micrograms of silver a day, half of that amount from our diet.

Humans have evolved with efficient methods of dealing with that intake, however. Over 99 percent is readily excreted from the body.

Is silver harmful to humans? Unlike other metals such as lead and mercury, silver is not toxic to humans and is not known to cause cancer, reproductive or neurological damage, or other chronic adverse effects."

-- Dartmouth University Toxic Metals Research Program

Oops…my bad! Obviously those guys over at Dartmouth are a bunch of snake oil peddlers, right? Ahhh…not so fast. Actually, the Dartmouth University Toxic Metals Research Program is known to be one of the best research programs of its kind…in the world.

Hmmm. That's strike four for the so-called "quack busters" and their ilk. Are you even allowed four strikes? Well, when you're dealing with the mentality that says natural health products and regimens are "quackery" and synthetic chemicals and drugs are "real medicine," you cut them a little slack by throwing them a few extra slow pitches, right?

Here’s a quote from a very popular best-selling health book written by two of the top natural health experts in the United States today, Dr. James F. Balch, M.D. and his wife, Phyllis A. Balch, CNC. Let’s see what they have to say about colloidal silver:

"Taken internally, colloidal silver can be used to fight infection. It has been shown to be effective against more that 650 disease-causing organisms, including Escherichia coli (E. coli) bacteria and the fungus Candida albicans."

-- Prescription For Nutritional Healing by Phyllis A Balch CNC and James F Balch, M.D., pg 66

Blasphemy! You can’t say that, Dr. Balch. After all, it goes against the orthodox medical view.

Oh? What’s that you say? You are a medical doctor? Ahem! Excuse me, sir.
Well, now that we’re clearly on a roll, let’s see if any other bona-fide medical physicians use colloidal silver to good effect. Here’s a quote from another medical doctor, author and educator, discussing one of his colleague’s clinical experiences inhaling colloidal silver into the lungs to treat pneumonia, through a device called a nebulizer:

"Dr. Marcial-Vega has had considerable clinical experience with a colloidal silver preparation that contains between 20 and 25 parts of silver per million parts of water.

This preparation has proven effective in patients with HIV in quickly resolving pneumonias due to pneumocystis, streptococcal, staphylococcal, klebsiella and fungal infections. In the hospital, the therapy is administered by a special nebulizer as well as orally."

-- Physicians Guide To Natural Health Products That Work, by James Howenstine, M.D., pg 262

“Considerable clinical experience”? “Proven effective in patients with HIV”? “Quickly resolving pneumonias due to pneumocystis, streptococcal, staphylococcal, klebsiela and fungal infections”?

This must be some kind of mistake, right? Surely Dr. Howenstine is misconstruing Dr. Marcial-Vega’s clinical experience with colloidal silver. After all, this Dr. Marcial Vega sounds like some kind of charlatan, right?

Let’s see what the famous Health Science Institute had to say back in 2001 about Dr. Marcial-Vega’s clinical work with colloidal silver. Maybe they’ll set the record straight on this topic:

Just in his last decade of medical practice, Dr. Marcial-Vega has treated hundreds of people with a variety of viral, fungal, and bacterial pneumonias. And of all the available treatments, he has seen the greatest success with nebulizer treatments using a colloidal silver preparation.
Silver has long been known for its anti-bacterial properties, and the nebulizer allows the mineral to reach the lungs and kill harmful bacteria. Now, in the face of the anthrax threat, he believes it can do the same thing with anthrax spores.

'We are constantly filtering all kinds of bacteria through our lungs,' explained Dr. Marcial-Vega. Normally, a healthy body is able to kill off any dangerous bacteria on its own. But in the case of illness, like pneumonia, or an especially lethal bacteria like anthrax, the body may need some extra help.
For anthrax prevention, he recommends a daily nebulizer treatment with 4 cc's of colloidal silver. By following this protocol, Dr. Marcial-Vega says your body can likely kill off the anthrax spores before you even know you were exposed.

Colloidal silver may even be useful to treat cutaneous anthrax with the preparation being directly applied to the affected skin. Dr. Marcial-Vega says there are no concerns about using this treatment because colloidal silver has no toxicity and no side effects.

He has used the colloidal silver nebulizer treatments on infants, the elderly, and AIDS patients with pneumonia and has seen great results. All have responded quickly to the treatment even when no other approach seemed to help, and no one reported any adverse reactions."

-- Health Science Institute e-alert, October 2001

Well, that proves it. This Dr. Marcial-Vega is clearly just another quack. A real snake oil salesman of the highest order, claiming to have cured all kinds of potentially deadly infections with colloidal silver.

Ahhh…once again…not quite. In fact, he’s a bona fide M.D. He interned at Johns Hopkins Hospital and School of Medicine. And he was an instructor at the Washington University School of Medicine from 1988 to 1990. What’s more, he was also a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Miami School of Medicine from 1990 to 1994.

Dang…maybe there really is something to this colloidal silver stuff, after all, huh? Dr. Marcial-Vega seems to think so. This is from the section of his web site titled “Colloidal Silver”:

“Orally, take one teaspoon three times a day for any type of infection.
Nebulization- Excellent for respiratory tract infections such as pneumonia and bronchitis. Get a nebuliser machine and a mask. These can be found at most pharmacies.

Put 15 cc (two teaspoons) in the included receptacle, turn on the machine and breathe deeply and slowly for approximately 15 minutes or until all the liquid is gone. Repeat three times a day for colds, pneumonias, bronchitis and sinusitis.

If it makes you cough too much, add 20-30 grains of sea salt to the liquid just before nebulizing and shake.

This is a natural antibiotic that contains water and silver in a colloidal suspension. It is effective against bacteria, viruses and fungi.”

-- Dr. Victor Marcial-Vega, M.D.

Well, there you have another well-known, licensed and bona-fide medical doctor and medical instructor with credentials out the ying-yang, affirming the benefits of colloidal silver usage.

Could all of these people possibly be quacks? Here’s another medical doctor who agrees that colloidal silver is a wonderful remedy for pneumonia-type illnesses:

"I have a friend who has suffered for years from chronic pneumonitis, caused by Pseudomonas. Sputum cultures were consistently positive, despite massive doses of horribly expensive antibiotics.
Then colloidal silver was suggested, and taken. Sputum cultures since have been negative, and the patient’s general health and vitality greatly improved.

Her internist can’t deny the improvement, but won’t attribute it to the silver, of course! It would have occurred anyway; the silver just happened to come on the scene at the right time. Uh-huh."

-- Dr. Paul Hine, M.D.

As Dr. Hine points out, among certain members of the orthodox medical community there seems to be a deep and abiding disregard for the use of antibacterial colloidal silver. Could it be they’ve read too many negative propaganda reports from the so-called “quack busters” and “skeptics” like Dr. Joe Schwarcz?

Fortunately, there are many, many more doctors like Dr. Hine who actually understand the science behind the substance, and who have witnessed with their own eyes the amazing healing benefits of colloidal silver.
Here’s another one:

Silver ions stimulate the lymphatic system by cleaning out the dead cells and bringing oxygen to the healthy cells.

-- Dr. Stephen West, DL, PMD (son of Dr. C. Samuel West, DN, ND, renowned chemist and internationally recognized lymphologist)

Oh, shit…can you actually say that? After all, according to the FDA, there’s no evidence whatsoever that colloidal silver has any purpose in the human body, or is effective at doing anything.

So, says the FDA, absolutely nobody should be ingesting it for healing illnesses or diseases, or even for cleaning dead cells out their lymph glands!
And of course, the so-called “skeptics” and “quack busters” toe the FDA line, claiming colloidal silver is little more than “quackery,” “snake oil” and “charlatanism,” and that there’s “no scientific evidence” for benefits from ingesting it.

So how can prestigious doctors, clinical researchers and scientists such as those above claim that colloidal silver is such a phenomenally beneficial healing substance? After alI, I thought you weren’t allowed to disagree with the FDA? Isn’t that against the law, or something?

Let’s try another expert, and see if we can find somebody who will actually agree with the so-called “quack busters” like Dr. Joe Schwarcz and assure us that colloidal silver use is unsafe:

"Few things in life are as cut-and-dried as the fact that silver is completely safe when used within normal limits."

-- Herbert Slavin, M.D., director of the Institute of Advanced Medicine in Lauderhill, Florida

All right, that just about does it! You just can’t say things like that, even if you are an M.D. and director of a well-known medical institute. It’s just not right, according to the FDA. After all, they and their “quack buster” followers have assured us that colloidal silver is “all risk and no benefit.”

Maybe an expert from the Center for Drug Research, and former director of a major city Poison Control Center, will set the record straight for us, once and for all times:

"Common substances like table salt and aspirin are harmless with normal use, but excessive intake can become toxic and even life-threatening. With normal responsible usage, silver supplements are entirely harmless to humans."

-- Jeffrey Blumer, M.D., Ph.D., director of the Center for Drug Research, former director of the Greater Cleveland Poison Control Center

Entirely harmless? Are you kidding me? Surely the so-called “skeptic” groups and “quack busters” wouldn’t continue to assure us that colloidal silver is dangerously toxic, if it wasn’t so. Right?

Let’s see if we can find a more reasonable, orthodox view of colloidal silver and its safety and effectiveness. This time we’ll go to a medical practitioner with over 37 years of bona-fide medical practice…

…including a Hero in Medicine award from the Palm Beach County Medical Society, an Outstanding Service Award from the National Association of Medical Examiners…and former Board President of the Florida Osteopathic Medical Association.

Surely someone with such prestigious medical credentials and sterling character as Dr. Ron Surowitz, D.O., M.D., will finally set us straight on the use of colloidal silver.

Let’s see:

"Sometimes a treatment can be worse than the illness, but not in the case of Colloidal Silver.

I have my patients spray or swish Colloidal Silver in their mouths from one to three times daily, depending on the severity of their condition…or, in a dose of one quarter to one teaspoon, and even up to one tablespoon, one to three times daily for situations that are more problematic.

I also have them use it in small amounts daily as a preventative...It's interesting how many of my patients improve with the use of Colloidal Silver. It enhances the immune system where other antibiotics cause yeast overgrowth...

...[As an example] one patient had persistent yeast infections. Having had no success with both prescription and non-prescription treatments, she called me, at her wit's end.

I suggested that she try a douche of two teaspoons of Colloidal Silver in a quart of water. Three days later she was evaluated in my office. The symptoms of her yeast infection had vanished, and there was no visible sign of infection."

-- Dr. Ron Surowitz, D.O., M.D., former head of the Florida Osteopathic Medical Association

Are we starting to see a trend here, yet? I sure hope so. It sure seems like there’s a LOT of bona-fide medical, science and clinical research experts who believe colloidal silver usage is…well…beneficial as all get-out!
Here’s another interesting quote, this time from the author of a popular book on colloidal chemistry:

"...metallic silver in colloidal suspension...yield silver ions in such a quantity as to have a detrimental effect on microorganisms but slowly enough not to be irritating to the tissues.

The colloidal silver particles provide a continuous source of these ions, yet the particles are not absorbed by the body tissue taken en masse in true solution by the body fluids; consequently, colloidal silver can be applied directly to delicate mucous membranes, such as those in the eye, with no irritation and with beneficial results...The colloidal particles diffuse gradually throughout the blood and give prolonged therapeutic action."

-- Robert J. Hartman, in his book, Colloid Chemistry

“Diffuse gradually through the blood”? “Give prolonged therapeutic action”?
Now hold your horses! Didn’t Canada’s “Mr. Science” assure us, in no uncertain terms, that colloidal silver has no benefit whatsoever in the human body? And that it’s unsafe to boot?

Hmmm. The world seems to be full of quacks. So let’s keep looking. Surely if we continue to look hard enough we’ll find an expert who will get us back on track. After all, there must be someone out there who will stand with Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, and verify for us the utter uselessness of colloidal silver. Let’s try a pharmacist:

"Many strains of pathogenic microbes, viruses, fungi, bacteria or any other single celled pathogen resistant to other antibiotics are killed on contact by colloidal silver, and are unable to mutate. However, it does not harm tissue-cell enzymes and friendly bacteria."

-- Ron Barnes, PhD., Pharmacist, Capital Drugs

Well, apparently you just can’t trust a pharmacist. Right? After all, they’re not medical practitioners. They’re just pill pushers.

So let’s ignore that quote, too, and see what a team of bona-fide clinical medical researchers have to say about colloidal silver:

Study Synopsis: 88 patients with peptic ulcers orally ingested tablets containing colloidal silver oxide over a period of 9 days. Within 6 weeks, all cases except one were healed. The particle size of the silver oxide was "three-tenths of a micron and smaller."

-- Rendin, Larry J, Gamba, Carl L., and Johnson, Walllace M. 1958. Colloidal oxide of silver in the treatment of peptic ulcer. Pennsylvania Medical Journal. 61: 612-614.

Well, that oughta give the so-called “skeptics” and “quack busters” an ulcer or two, wouldn’t you say?

Alright. The “debunkers” keep striking out today. But let’s not give up. Instead, let’s continue our search for an expert who will agree with Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, and assure us that colloidal silver usage is pure bunk.

This time we’ll go with a board certified clinical nutritionist. Surely a highly trained clinical nutritionist would know that colloidal silver is so worthless and so risky it has no place whatsoever in the human body, right?

"Colloidal silver is the product the FDA and many mainstream medical people love to hate. Listening to them you would think every person taking colloidal silver is going to turn gray with silver accumulation in their skin (argyria).

Their worst nightmare is people taking colloidal silver to combat the H1N1 swine flu – the nightmare for them is that it might actually work.

…The high efficacy in the use of silver to kill bacteria and fungus is not in question by anyone. This does not mean it kills every type of bacteria or fungus. And in the ones it does kill it does not mean it kills all of them.
It simply means that the antibiotic properties of silver are quite potent – and the risk to human health in terms of toxicity is negligible.

This is a far better risk/benefit profile than commonly used antibiotics."

-- Byron J. Richards, CCN (Board Certified Clinical Nutritionist, charter member of the International & American Association of Clinical Nutritionists

Okay, fine. Nutritionists are all quacks anyway, right?

Just like those medical doctors, clinical researchers, pharmacists, chemistry experts and drug researchers we’ve been reading about above. All completely nutzo!

So let’s see what a bona-fide microbiologist – a professor from a major university, no less -- has to say. Surely he’ll tell us there’s no possible human use for colloidal silver:

"The data suggests that with the low toxicity associated with colloidal silver, in general, and the broad spectrum of antimicrobial activity of this colloidal silver preparation, this preparation may be effectively used as an alternative to antibiotics."

-- Dr. Ron Leavitt, Ph.D., Professor of Microbiology, Brigham Young University

Oh, oh. Did he just say colloidal silver may be used effectively “as an alternative to antibiotics”? Well, maybe ALL of these experts are quacks.

Let’s try a dentist. Surely a dentist would know that colloidal silver can’t possibly be helpful for treating disease conditions.

"Colloidal silver is very effective in treating periodontal disease (gum disease). My patients enjoy the clean fresh breath as colloidal silver immediately cleanses the mouth and destroys odor-causing bacteria. I would recommend that colloidal silver solutions be used after each dental procedure or surgery to eliminate infection and speed healing."

-- S.R. Cobble, D.D.S.

Well, that didn’t work out the way I thought it would. But I know if we just keep looking, we’ll find someone to back up the views of Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, who swears colloidal silver is a useless sham.

Let’s try another medical doctor, this time a Board Certified M.D. with over 30 years of practice in internal medicine who runs his own medical institute and has hospital privileges. Undoubtedly he’ll back up the contention of the so-called “quack busters” and “skeptics” like Dr. Joe Schwarcz, and assure us that that colloidal silver usage is worthless:

"...Ionic silver is increasingly being recognized for its broad-spectrum antimicrobial qualities and the fact that it presents virtually none of the side-effects related to antibiotics.

Ionic silver is entirely non-toxic to the body...Reports of any pathogens developing resistance to ionic silver are rare. Some reports indicate it even kills drug-resistant strains of germs.

Ionic silver is also a powerful tissue-healing agent, so much so that it has been used topically for decades in burn centers and currently represents one of the fastest growing sectors – if not the fastest growing sector – in wound care today.

The fact that ionic silver is effective against a very broad range of bacteria is well established and, due to recent advances in the delivery of ionic silver together with the problems associated with antibiotics, it is being used in a rapidly growing range of dietary-supplement, medical, and industrial products.

...A study at the University of Arizona recently showed ionic silver to be effective against the coronavirus that researchers use as the surrogate for SARS."

-- Herbert Slavin, M.D., founder and director of the Institute of Advanced Medicine, Lauderhill, Florida

Okay. Another quack, obviously. The world must be absolutely brimming over with them. But here’s a pair of well-known medical doctors who will surely let us know if colloidal silver is quackery, or the real deal. After all, their medical reputations are at stake:

“...the collective authoritative medical literature has documented efficacy of silver's virotoxicity against over 24 viruses...A broad-spectrum anti-viral agent that really works is needed to combat over 200 viruses that cause Upper Respiratory Tract Infections.

Undoubtedly oligodynamic silver fits this bill...Emerging medical studies confirm the stellar, broad-spectrum virotoxic efficacy of oligodynamic silver both in vitro and in vivo.”

-- Dr Eric Gordon, MD and Dr. Kent Holtorf, MD, Townsend Letter for Doctors, "A Promising Cure for Upper Respiratory Tract Infection Pandemics”

Wow…did they just say that both in the test tube and in the body (in vitro and in vivo), silver has proven itself to display broad-spectrum toxicity to disease-causing viruses? (See www.ColloidalSilverKillsViruses.com for more information on studies demonstrating colloidal silver to be effective against viruses.)

If it’s beginning to look to you as if the so-called “skeptics” and “quack busters” who constantly rail against colloidal silver usage don’t know what the heck they’re talking about…you’re absolutely right!

For example, the prestigious American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine also disagrees with Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz.

Let’s see what they have to say about colloidal silver usage:

"Often called the 'penicillin of alternative medicine,' colloidal silver disables the enzymes that bacteria, parasites, viruses, and fungi rely on to use oxygen. Unable to 'breathe,' the organisms die and are eliminated from the body.

While an antibiotic drug may kill several types of disease organisms, colloidal silver delivers the kiss of death to at least 650 disease organisms. In addition, colloidal silver can be taken over long periods of time because microorganisms cannot develop a resistance to it.

…Among the conditions colloidal silver has controlled are severe burns, acne, boils, candida and yeast infections, chronic fatigue syndrome, digestive problems and colitis, ear and sinus infections, herpes, shingles, lupus, malaria, viral and fungal infections, blood parasites, rheumatoid arthritis, and ringworm.

Colloidal silver also has been effective in treating cancer and AIDS if used at certain point in the disease cycle when infected cells have reverted to a more primitive way of using oxygen, however these uses of colloidal silver are not clinically proven.

...The recommended dosage of colloidal silver depends upon the concentration of the product you are using, which is expressed as "ppm" or "parts per million."

Concentrations range from 5ppm to 500ppm. In general, the greater the ppm the larger the colloidal silver particle size. This variable is important because it takes a smaller particle size to kill a virus vs. bacteria.
Some companies have developed technology that allows increased ppm while preserving a smaller particle size.

Colloidal silver can be taken internally in a small amount of distilled drinking water. It also can be applied topically to cuts and open sores and can be inhaled or sprayed using an atomizer."

-- The American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, Physician & Practitioner Administered Procedures and Therapies

Okay. I admit it. I’m stumped. I just can’t find anyone of any repute whatsoever who will agree with Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz, about colloidal silver. But wait. Here’s one. Since “Dr. Joe” used the topic of skin staining (argyria) as a means of scaring people away from colloidal silver usage in his article in the Montreal Gazette

…let’s find out what a member of the New York Academy of Sciences and the American Association for the Advancement of Science, who happens to have some very in-depth scientific knowledge on this specific topic, has to say:

"...you should be advised that we recently completed an extensive review of the scientific literature on the safety of silver, especially as it relates to its one known potential side effect, namely, Argyria.

Argyia is an irreversible discoloration of the pigment (skin) caused by excessive silver intake or chronic exposure to silver by certain tissues. The amount of silver required to develop Argyria is estimated [by the EPA] to be 3.8 grams per day.

By comparison standard 10 ppm colloidal silver contains silver in amounts equaling less than 1 milligram of silver (1,000 micrograms = 1 milligram; 1,000 milligrams - 1 gram)…

…which therefore represents an amount approximately 1/500th to 1/1000th of the amount of silver considered to be a risk in the development of Argyria.

Most cases of Argyria reported in the medical literature over the last 100 years involved chronic intravenous or intramuscular use of the silver preparations, most often involving a silver drug prescribed by physicians which in most cases contained silver nitrate.

Other cases of Argyria reported in the medical literature involve application of silver preparations used for many months or years in the treatment of the eye or vagina for certain diseases.

We could not locate a single case of orally consumed colloidal silver manufactured in the last 25 years causing Argyria in our review of the literature.

This is probably due to the low levels of silver contained in such preparations, since only very small amounts of silver are needed for its antiseptic effect.

Humans consume approximately 100 micrograms of silver every day in the diet. Additional amounts within this range would be considered safe by all reasonable estimates, especially if the amount needed to develop Argyria would be the equivalent of 380,000 micrograms (or 3.8 grams) of silver a day.

As for the efficacy of silver preparations, we found considerable scientific evidence published over the last 75 years that a number of silver compounds can be effective germicidal (antiseptic) agents against several hundred pathogenic organisms.”

-- Alexander G. Schauss, Ph.D., Emeritus member of the New York Academy of Sciences, member American Association for the Advancement of Science, former Chairman of the Food Policy Council of the National Council for Public Health Policy, member of the Government's Commission on Dietary Supplements

The Final Word…

As you can clearly see, there are a LOT of bona-fide science, medical and clinical research experts who have diametrically opposite views about colloidal silver usage and safety than those of Canada’s intrepid “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz.

Of course, so-called "skeptics" like Schwarcz would probably not hesitate to label the above authorities as "quacks" and "charlatans" and "snake oil peddlers" since that's what they do with just about anyone who disagrees with their bought-and-paid-for views against nutritional supplements and natural health regimens.

In my humble opinion, the entire agenda of the so-called "debunkers" like Dr. Joe Schwarcz and their "quack busters" compadres is to use cleverly designed propaganda, combined with an aura of authority to confuse and befuddle the public into believing natural substances like colloidal silver are nothing more than "snake oil."

And they spend millions of dollars doing so – even in the face of knowing that huge numbers of their peers in the worldwide medical, science and clinical community completely disagree with them.

If you didn’t know better, you’d almost have to think these so-called “quack busters” are working behind-the-scenes for Big Pharma, or the big multi-national chemical corporations, or some other nefarious bunch.

But of course, we all know they’re just spending those millions of dollars out of their own pocketbooks and out of the goodness of their hearts, to “educate” the public about the nefarious hidden dangers of completely natural substances…

…while promoting the wondrous benefits of the chemical-laden foods, toxic chemical food additives and synthetic drugs brought to us by the big multi-national corporations behind Big Pharma and Big Farma.

It’s Up to YOU…

So I’ll have to leave it to you, dear reader, to decide between “Dr. Joe’s” denigration of colloidal silver, and the expert opinions of the real-life scientists, medical doctors and clinical researchers cited throughout this article.

Do your own research. Conduct your own due diligence on colloidal silver and its usage. And decide for yourself who’s right and who’s wrong.

But always understand that there are paid mouthpieces out there who claim to have the “public interest” at heart, but who in reality are nothing more than paid shills for special interests like Big Pharma, Big Farma, and other huge multi-national commercial conglomerates…

…and who therefore have a vested financial interest in frightening the public into abandoning relatively safe and effective natural substances like colloidal silver, and instead, paying through the nose for synthetic chemical concoctions and drugs that are so very often toxic, unsafe and decidedly unnatural.

So the next time you run across an article by a public figure or celebrity of some type denouncing and denigrating the use of colloidal silver, don’t just accept the sensationalistic claims at face value.

Do yourself a favor and dig a little bit deeper like I did. You just might discover information that would lead you to believe the public figure is actually a paid propaganda mouthpiece hired because his aura of authority and skills at misdirection are exactly what his financial benefactors want from him.

More great information on colloidal silver coming in the next issue. Until then, I remain…

Yours for the safe, sane and responsible use of colloidal silver,

Steve Barwick, author

Helpful Links:

Important Note and Disclaimer: The contents of this Ezine have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Information conveyed herein is from sources deemed to be accurate and reliable, but no guarantee can be made in regards to the accuracy and reliability thereof. The author, Steve Barwick, is a natural health journalist with over 30 years of experience writing professionally about natural health topics. He is not a doctor. Therefore, nothing stated in this Ezine should be construed as prescriptive in nature, nor is any part of this Ezine meant to be considered a substitute for professional medical advice. Nothing reported herein is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The author is simply reporting in journalistic fashion what he has learned during the past 17 years of journalistic research into colloidal silver and its usage. Therefore, the information and data presented should be considered for informational purposes only, and approached with caution. Readers should verify for themselves, and to their own satisfaction, from other knowledgeable sources such as their doctor, the accuracy and reliability of all reports, ideas, conclusions, comments and opinions stated herein. All important health care decisions should be made under the guidance and direction of a legitimate, knowledgeable and experienced health care professional. Readers are solely responsible for their choices. The author and publisher disclaim responsibility or liability for any loss or hardship that may be incurred as a result of the use or application of any information included in this Ezine.

Copyright 2012 | Life & Health Research Group, LLC | PO Box 1239 | Peoria AZ 85380-1239 | All rights reserved

Monday, March 5, 2012

Canada’s “Mr. Science” Labels Colloidal Silver Usage “Quackery”

A gentleman widely regarded to be the “Mr. Science” of Canada – Dr. Joe Schwarcz -- has published an article in the Montreal Gazette newspaper criticizing, ridiculing and disparaging the use of colloidal silver.

But is his criticism unbiased? Or is it paid propaganda? Is it based on real science? Or is it just more of the same old sensationalistic nonsense disguised as facts and given the aura of authority because it comes from a man of letters?

In this article, you’ll learn more about Canada’s “Mr. Science.” And you’ll get a good look at some of the interesting connections between him and a certain “skeptic” group that apparently spends millions of dollars on the task of denigrating the use of nutritional supplements.

What’s more, I’ll throw in a handful of corrupt multi-national corporations who peddle toxic chemicals to the public as well, and let you know how they might be connected to Canada’s infamous “Mr. Science.”

Finally, you’ll learn just a little bit more about the way self-styled “quack busters” like Dr. Schwarcz operate in their quest to promote the use of toxic drugs and chemicals, while planting negative information about colloidal silver and other natural healing modalities in the minds of the public.

In the process, you’ll see why you sometimes have to dig a little deeper for the truth when pop culture personalities like Canada’s “Mr. Science” use their aura of authority to bash a safe, natural infection-fighting remedy like colloidal silver that, in reality, has been demonstrated by medical science to be safe and highly effective for well over a century.

Hi, Steve Barwick here, for www.TheSilverEdge.com...

Another self-appointed “expert” has decided to publicly deride the use of colloidal silver.
This time it’s a Dr. Joe Schwarcz, director of Montreal, Canada’s McGill University Office for Science and Society.

He’s widely regarded to be the “Mr. Science” of Canada, and is regularly seen on television programs explaining science to the public.

Indeed, according to his profile on the McGill University web site, the man is “dedicated to demystifying science for the public, the media and students.”

Nice credentials, huh?

After all, making science more understandable for the general public is certainly a worthy endeavor…if you’re telling them the truth…and if you’re not operating under a hidden agenda – particularly a paid hidden agenda.

In a recent news article written by Schwarcz and published in Canada’s Montreal Gazette newpaper, Schwarcz sang the praises of silver’s antimicrobial qualities…

…but he quickly labeled as “quackery” the use of colloidal silver as a nutritional supplement.

Here’s what he had to say about colloidal silver:

“Unfortunately, quackery often rides along the coattails of science. And so it is in this case. Numerous websites promote the use of ‘colloidal silver’ as a cure for cancer, diabetes, HIV infection and herpes.

[It] may well have an antibacterial effect in a petri dish, but that is a long way from having an antibacterial effect when taken internally.

No scientific evidence supports the benefit of ingesting any form of colloidal silver.

Making health claims on its behalf is illegal, but colloidal silver can be sold as a dietary supplement.
That is a curiosity because humans have no dietary requirement for silver and there is no such thing as silver deficiency.”

Schwarcz goes on to describe former U.S. Senate candidate Stan Jones, who contracted a mild case of argyria from excessive colloidal silver usage back in 2000, saying:

“He started to take a colloidal silver preparation that he made himself by passing an electric current through a solution equipped with silver electrodes.

Unfortunately he used too high a voltage and his solution contained a great deal of silver. He turned blue.

But he is not singing the blues, maintaining that he is healthy and still dopes himself with colloidal silver. Pretty dopey actually.”

All in all, the portion of Mr. Schwarcz’s article dedicated to ridiculing the use of colloidal silver is composed of the usual cacophony of carefully selected misleading statements disguised as "facts"…

…along with subtle scare tactics designed to frighten the public into thinking everyone who tries colloidal silver will “turn blue”…and of course a hefty helping of immature name-calling and sarcasm thrown in for good measure.

In short, there’s no science at all in these statements from the man known as Canada’s “Mr. Science.”
Unfortunately, these types of journalistic drive-by-shootings are all too common among those who criticize the use of colloidal silver and other safe effective natural health remedies.

After all, when you don’t have the science to back up your statements, all you have left to use in order to make your point is exaggeration, misdirection, fear and ridicule.

In part II of this article, which will be available next week, we’ll take a look at what some real medical and science experts have to say about colloidal silver and its usage, including their comments on its profound effectiveness and safety.

And when we do, it will become abundantly obvious that Mr. Schwarcz should have interviewed at least a few of these experts for his news article – if only for balance and fairness -- before he decided to take pen in hand and ridicule colloidal silver.

But first, let’s take a closer look at Mr. Schwarcz, his apparent agenda, and some of his compatriots. When we do, I think you’ll see that in spite of his protestations to the contrary, balance and fairness (and truth) are indeed the very last things on his mind.

A Closer Look at Canada’s “Mr. Science”

One of the very first things I discovered as I began to research Mr. Schwarcz and his background is that he’s a long-time proponent of vaccines, claiming they’re the “greatest scientific advance that has ever been introduced in the history of the world.”

Hey, no bias there, right?

(Though I suspect this vaccine victim, and this vaccine victim, and this vaccine victim and this vaccine victim, and these vaccine victims and these vaccine victims would tend to disagree with Mr. Schwarcz’s contentions.)

He even goes so far as to ridicule actors Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey for their public anti-vaccine stances, and for bringing to light many of the horrific incidences of death and devastation being caused by vaccines.

And he casually brushes off the growing public resistance to vaccines as being caused by “conspiracy theories”…

…frequently referring to anti-vaccine advocates as “conspiracy nuts” and “graduates of the University of Google, for whom evidence-based medicine is a foreign concept.”

If it’s beginning to look like the use of disdain and ridicule is one of “Mr. Science’s” chief tools-of-the-trade…that’s because it is!

How very scientific of him, right? But wait…it gets better…much better!

The Monsanto Connection?

For example, according to an article by investigative journalist Alex Constantine, far from being an unbiased educator of the public, our intrepid “Mr. Science” of Canada has a long history of using his public stature to lull the public into believing that…

…toxic chemicals produced by giant multi-national biotechnology conglomerates are actually good for you!

Indeed, says Constantine, in reality Schwarcz is a “shill for Monsanto” and other large multi-national biotechnology corporations.

Constantine explains that huge corporations like these use public figures like Schwarcz to propagandize the public into accepting toxic chemical food additives, genetically modified foods and chemically grown foods as a normal part of our daily diet.

For example, according to Constantine, “Dr. Schwarcz writes that aspartame is perfectly safe to consume -- a verdict contradicted by scores of independent studies, and one that only the insane could endorse.”

Witches, Vampires, Evil Eyes and Jews…Oh, My!

Indeed, ignoring reams of scientific data against aspartame and other toxic chemicals now found in foods and consumer goods…

…the intrepid Dr. Schwarcz explains away the devastation to people’s health being caused by these toxic chemicals as nothing more than by-products of their over-active imaginations.

Says Schwarcz in his book, Dr. Joe and What You Didn’t Know: 99 Fascinating Questions About Chemistry, people who believe they’ve been harmed by chemical-laden foods, or vaccines, or other such products are basically just…well…mentally unstable.

He writes:

“When there is no ready scientific explanation, we invent one.

That’s why the Black Plague was blamed on witches and Jews, the waxy pallor of tuberculosis victims was blamed on vampires, and migraines were blamed on the evil eye…

People need to identify cause-and-effect relationships even when they don’t exist.

Today, instead of blaming our ailments on witches and evil eyes, we blame them on chemicals.”

Ahhh, yes. It’s all in our heads.

You see, all of those poor little screaming purple babies who go into convulsions after being vaccinated, and who are ending up with horrific developmental diseases like autism or worse…
…and all of those painful and degenerative side effects from aspartame and other toxic chemicals now being loaded into our foods and other consumer goods…

…none of that is real…not at all.

Instead, it’s ALL just part of our deep-rooted psychological need to blame things on witches and vampires and evil eyes and Jews.

Clearly, the disdain and ridicule of the general public demonstrated by Dr. Joe Schwarcz apparently knows no bounds.

But where does the ridicule end, and the “science” begin?

Well, most of the time…it simply doesn’t. To Schwarcz, ridicule and hyperbole are quite sufficient, thank you.

After all, who needs real science when you can simply paint proponents of nature’s bounty as a bunch of mindless, superstitious nuts and kooks?

Funding From the Dark Side? Follow the Money!

Constantine goes on to justify his claim that Schwarcz is a “shill for Monsanto” by pointing out that at least some of Schwarcz’s funding in the past has come from a group called the Council for Biotechnology Information, also known as CBI…

…which is essentially the propaganda arm of the major multi-national corporations involved in the promulgation of “agricultural biotechnology” i.e., the worldwide production of chemical-laden foods and arguably toxic food additives.

In past years, CBI has apparently helped fund McGill University's Office for Science and Society, which of course is headed by our intrepid advocate of chemical-laden foods and food additives, Dr. Joe Schwarcz.

Constantine goes on to quote a document from the Council for Biotechnology Information in which they apparently openly admit to their financial support of Schwarcz’s Office for Science and Society at McGill University…

…as well as admitting that the financial support is for the expressed purpose of garnering greater public support for the increasing usage of chemicals in farming and food production (underlining is my own):

“…the Council believes that fostering acceptance begins and ends with sharing balanced and science-based information, delivered by credible spokespeople and organizations, with the consuming public.
To this end, the Council’s integrated and comprehensive communications program is geared at increasing the number of informed consumers and spurring acceptance of biotechnology in food production.

"Among the Council for Biotechnology Information’s efforts in Canada, we have...Provided arm’s length support to diverse organizations such as McGill University’s Office for Chemistry and Society..."

Do you see how this works?

According to Constantine, the big multi-national chemical companies find an acknowledged public spokesman like Dr. Joe Schwarcz, and apparently fund his office. In return he speaks out publicly in favor of their toxic, chemical-laden concoctions which they loosely refer to as “food” or “food additives,” and against the growing back-to-nature, non-chemical organic foods movement.

Indeed, today CBI’s membership roster includes some of the leading multinational biotechnology companies and trade associations in the world -- purveyors of genetically modified foods, chemical farming and toxic chemical food additives.

According to the CBI’s web site, these companies include:

  • Monsanto
  • BASF
  • Bayer CropScience
  • Dow AgroSciences LLC
  • DuPont
  • Syngenta
Of course, Monsanto was recently fined $700 million for poisoning people with PCBs -- a chemical which causes a host of health problems in humans ranging from learning disorders to cancer.
Later, Monsanto was fined another $2.5 million for mislabeling and illegally selling genetically engineered cotton seeds.

And in 2005, Monsanto admitted to violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, and of making false entries into its books and records in the course of a US Department of Justice case.

In 2007 Monsanto was fined by a French court for misleading the public about the environmental impact of its herbicide Roundup.

And as Mike Adams, of NaturalNews.com has recently reported, Monsanto has even infiltrated key positions in the U.S. government, and has hired key government officials to help pass legislation favorable to the company:

“…leaked documents now reveal that Monsanto has also deeply infiltrated the United States government…U.S. diplomats are actually working for Monsanto to push their agenda along with other key government officials.”

Other members of the CBI group have equally checkered legal pasts.

For example, BASF has reportedly been fined hundreds of millions of dollars for crimes ranging from antitrust violations (price-fixing)…to environmental pollution…to damaging the health of their workers in foreign countries with toxins.

Bayer was also fined millions of dollars in a price-fixing scheme to keep the price of aspirin abnormally high, as well as millions more dollars in fines for paying illegal kickbacks to medical suppliers to switch patients over to their products.

Bayer later paid $750 million as a settlement with U.S. farmers for ruining their rice crops with unapproved genetically modified rice.

Are you beginning to get the picture?

Based on the evidence presented by Constantine, it appears Mr. Schwarcz has made a living, at least in part, as a paid propaganda mouthpiece for what are arguably some of the most corrupt multinational corporations on the face of the earth.

The Quack Buster Connection…

A little more digging on the internet, and – surprise! surprise! -- another little tidbit of interesting information pops up:

This “Mr. Science” of Canada is also a self-confessed natural health “skeptic” and “quack buster” who spends a significant portion of his time publicly ridiculing both natural supplements and proponents of natural health.

Or, as McGill University Publications puts it, Schwarcz is a “a tireless debunker of modern day snake oil peddlers.”

Go figure. Who’da guessed it?

He’s even written articles “debunking” various natural health remedies, regimens and alternative medicine practitioners for online public forums such as Canada’s notorious Quackery Watch web site.

And the more you dig, the more you learn.

Another Nefarious Source of Funding

According to another article in the Montreal Gazette, there’s even another source of funding for the intrepid Mr. Schwarcz.

This time, the funding comes from a well-known Canadian “philanthropist” and dedicated natural health skeptic, Mr. Lorne Trottier…

…who sits on the board of one of the world’s largest “skeptics” groups which holds symposiums ridiculing things like belief in God, and, of course, use of alternative medicine and nutritional supplements.

According to the Montreal Gazette:

“Charlatans and quacks beware - Joe Schwarcz has an extra $5.5 million to help put you out of business.

And, mark his words - the man behind McGill University's renowned Office for Science and Society won't rest until…

… every bottle of Goji juice, every ounce of mistletoe extract and every coffee enema has been revealed for the sham that they are.”

The new gift to McGill's faculty of science from philanthropist Lorne Trottier…

…It is believed to be the largest gift ever for science promotion in Canada, and Schwarcz says it will go a long way in his ‘battle against charlatans.’”

In other words, the “philanthropist” Mr. Trottier is funding Schwarcz’s propaganda campaign against alternative medicine and natural health -- apparently including colloidal silver -- to the tune of a whopping $5.5 million!

Nice work, I suppose, if you can get it!

And who is this “philanthropist,” Lorne Trottier? Well, according to internet sources he’s the uncle of famous Canadian atheist activist, Justin Trottier.

And he sits on the board of a group called CFI Canada (Center for Inquiry), which is described on Wikipedia as:

“…a non-profit educational organization with headquarters in the United States whose primary mission is to encourage evidence-based inquiry into…fringe science claims, alternative medicine…[and] religion.”

In other words, CFI is a so-called “skeptic” group composed of people who consider things like natural health, alternative medicine and even belief in God and religion…

…as unscientific forms of “quackery”!

Indeed, they reject and deny God, as well as His bountiful nature and its healing benefits. (Here’s a link to a CFI Canada video in which the group is seen holding an “atheist stand-up comedy” night, replete with a “de-Baptism” ceremony.)

Yes, according to the Montreal Gazette, Lorne Trottier, a board member of this group, is a large source of funding for Canada’s “Mr. Science,” Joe Schwarcz.

“Snake Oil” v/s “Evidence-Based Medicine”

According to Wikipedia, the CFI has grown into a worldwide organization since its establishment in the U.S. in 1991.

It’s opened numerous overseas branches – including opening a summertime “student exchange” program with Moscow State University (of course!) -- and has even gained “special consultative status” with the United Nations.

Indeed, CFI now appears to be one of the world’s largest and most well-funded of the so-called “skeptic” groups…

…to the point they hold conferences and events in major cities around the world to promote atheism, secular humanism, and the value of “evidence-based medicine” (read: Big Pharma’s toxic drugs and chemicals) over natural health remedies, which they constantly refer to as “snake oil.”

And guess who speaks at those big conferences and events?

Well, if you guessed that Canada’s intrepid “Mr. Science,” Dr. Joe Schwarcz is one of the featured guest speakers for CFI Canada-related events, give yourself a Brownie button, because you’re right on target.

Sometimes he also acts as a moderator for Trottier-related events, such as a recent talk on alternative medicine in which the topic was…


Schwarcz is also listed as an “Advisory Fellow” of CFI Canada, a leadership category within the group that appears to be directly under the Board of Directors and over the National Executive Council!

In short, he’s a big shot with the atheistic organization that despises God, ridicules faith and religion, and works to disparage natural health advocates and natural health remedies.

No wonder he got a $5.5 million dollar grant to bash proponents of natural health, from CFI Canada’s board member, Lorne Trottier!

Manipulating Internet Search Results…

But just what do these so-called “skeptic” groups do, besides holding meetings and railing against God and Goji berries?

Interestingly, the renowned investigative journalist Tim Bolen -- who for years now has exposed the sordid underbelly of the various so-called “quack buster” and “skeptics” groups and their adherents -- recently mentioned CFI and similar groups in an online article.

Bolen explained how some of these groups often work to manipulate the internet in an effort to make sure that only negative information about topics like natural health appear in the top tier of the Google search engine results.

Bolen wrote:

“There is an easily traceable pseudo-skeptic conspiracy going on.

It originates in the US, and, consequently, each and every component, each and every participant, no matter where they are, is subject to US law, and hence, US Courts.

Its sole purpose, now, is to control through Search Engine Optimization (SEO) techniques and anonymous manipulation of Wikipedia, information flow about health care on the internet.

…They have two areas of focus:

(1) The first page of Google and other search engine ranking, and
(2) control, by organized anonymous manipulation, of Wikipedia health pages. They want their version of life to be the only thing read on the internet.”

In other words, according to Bolen, the so-called “skeptics” groups and quack busters work quietly behind the scenes to make sure the top rankings in the Google search results are dominated by…

…either web sites that carry decidedly negative articles about natural health topics, or by web sites that passionately advocate for Big Pharma and their drugs, or Big Farma and their chemical-laden food additives and concoctions.

Indeed, according to Bolen, it appears that one of the main goals of some of these so-called “skeptic” organizations and “quack buster” groups…

… is to manipulate the search rankings through sneaky and sometimes even underhanded tactics such as “Google bombing”.

The idea behind “google bombing” is to make sure targeted natural health web sites are driven down in the search engine results, and only negative articles on targeted natural health subjects appear at the top of the Google search rankings.

According to CuteRank.net, “Google Bombing is when a group of sites such as blogs join forces to link to an unflattering page about a company or product such that this page rises to the top of the search results in Google.”

Take Colloidal Silver, For Example…

Want an example of the results of potential search engine manipulation? Here’s one I think you’ll find interesting:

Google the phrase “colloidal silver.”

At the time of this writing, when you Google that phrase, the very first listing you’ll see in Google’s organic rankings (i.e., non-paid advertising rankings) is a Wikipedia.com entry about medicinal silver.

The Wikipedia article is extremely negative about colloidal silver and disparaging of its usage – enough to scare anyone away from even thinking about using it.

The second Google ranking is the infamous Quackwatch.com web page on colloidal silver. It’s another extremely negative hit piece claiming that the infection-fighting substance is essentially useless, and constitutes significant “risk without benefit.”

Anyone reading that biased and distorted article would conclude that colloidal silver usage is unbelievably dangerous at best.

And the third Google ranking is the Mayo Clinic’s equally negative article on colloidal silver.

In other words, in the Google search rankings, out of a whopping 688,000 page results for the search term “colloidal silver,” the top three web sites ranked by Google are all decidedly negative regarding colloidal silver usage.

Those are the three web sites the vast majority of the public will click on when searching for information on colloidal silver, because they’re at the very top of the Google search rankings.

And of course, thanks to those high-ranking articles the public is always left with a decidedly negative opinion on colloidal silver usage.

Is that legitimate?

What are the chances that the top three Google search engine results for the phrase “colloidal silver” – out of well over a half million page results for that phrase -- would be decidedly negative ones?
Are the search rankings being purposely manipulated so that only negative information on colloidal silver is seen first by anyone searching for information on the substance?

Criminal Racketeering?

Bolen points out that if it can be demonstrated conclusively that “skeptic groups” or individuals within those groups have engaged in purposeful manipulation of the internet search results…

…(and based on the evidence he’s amassed, he believes it can indeed be demonstrated)…in some cases it may constitute criminal racketeering (RICO) on behalf of those involved.


Because natural health practitioners as well as natural health companies and products that are targeted by the search engine manipulators are not only being financially harmed by the blatant manipulation of search engine results, but their reputations are being harmed as well.

You may want to take some time to read Bolen’s January 2012 article here in order to gain a better understanding of the “skeptic” and “quack buster” scam against natural health…

…and the idea that at least some of these groups or individuals associated with them are purposely using tactics to manipulate and skew search engine results against natural health practitioners, companies and products.

And be sure to watch Bolen’s web site for the promised follow-up articles on this topic.

Anonymous Contributions?

Interestingly, according to Bolen, tax records show that CFI took in millions of dollars in contributions in recent years, much of which was listed as coming from “anonymous” donors.
But who could these “anonymous” donors be? Indeed, why would anyone donate millions upon millions of dollars to a group hell bent on disparaging goji berries and other popular natural health remedies?

Well, unfortunately the Schedule B of tax returns for such groups -- where the donors must be listed -- are not publicly accessible short of a lawsuit. But let’s ask the age-old question of “who benefits?”
Who benefits most when natural health remedies, natural health practitioners and natural health vendors are publicly denigrated…

…and as a result the public is left with a decidedly negative impression of substances like vitamins, minerals, herbs and nutritional supplements in general?

Answer that question and you just might be on the trail of the source of those anonymous millions of dollars in donations to so-called skeptics groups like CFI.

What’s more, according to Bolen, tax records also show that CFI apparently received millions more dollars in income reported on their taxes as “management fees.”


Bolen asks, “What do you suppose they managed? And who paid them to manage it? Maybe they manage Wikipedia health care articles? How about managing Search Engine Optimization (SEO) tactics designed to bring skeptic articles to the first page of Google?”

Bolen promises to answer those very pertinent questions in greater depth, in upcoming articles on his web site.

In Summary…

So to sum up, according to the Montreal Gazette it appears our intrepid colloidal silver basher – the “Mr. Science” of Canada, Dr. Joe Schwarcz – is now largely funded by Lorne Trottier, a self-described natural health “skeptic” who sits on the board of CFI Canada –

-- of which Dr. Schwarcz is an “Advisory Fellow,” and which, in turn, is a branch of the worldwide CFI organization that collects millions of dollars annually in donations and “management fees” from anonymous sources

-- allowing it to fund people who apparently spend a large part of their time making sure the public perception of subjects like alternative medicine and natural health practices are decidedly negative.
And according to investigative journalist Alex Constantine, the good Dr. Joe Schwarcz has also been funded through CBI, the organization promoting corrupt Big Farma multi-national corporate giants like Monsanto, Bayer and others.

Is it any wonder Schwarcz makes Youtube.com video after video and posts them online, ridiculing natural health and extolling the supposed virtues of chemical additives and chemical-laden foods?
Well, it must be nice to get paid to sit around all day and plot how to promote chemical additives while simultaneously working to scare the bejabbers out of the general public about the supposed “dangers” of natural health products.

Yes, I’m talking about those same evil natural health supplements like vitamins, minerals, amino acids, herbs, colloidal silver and similar products that haven’t caused even a single death in 27 years

… while supposedly “safe” and fully regulated chemicals and pharmaceutical drugs continue to send as many as 200,000 innocent men, women and little children to early graves each year…in America alone.

Truth or Paid Propaganda?

See what happens when you dig just a little bit deeper, rather than taking a popular authority figure at their word for something?

Considering Mr. Schwarcz’s agenda-driven background as an apparent propaganda shill for major multinational biochemical corporations, and as a “kept man” by God-hating natural health “skeptic” Lorne Trottier of CFI Canada…

…I didn’t have to wonder too long why he didn’t bother to interview even a single well-known expert on colloidal silver usage for his thoroughly negative article in the Montreal Gazette.

After all, real experts on the subject of colloidal silver would point out the truth about the infection-fighting benefits of the substance, based both on the science as well as on their own clinical and practical experiences.

And the truth is not always what bought-and-paid-for shills want the public to hear. After all, they’re paid to mislead the public – usually under the guise of “educating” the public. (Yes, that’s my educated opinion.)

Like Joe Schwarcz, the so-called “skeptics” often claim to base their contentions on “science.”
But as we’ve seen, what they usually end up doing is dispensing with the science and resorting to exaggeration, misdirection, sensationalism, name-calling, disdain and ridicule, instead.

So for the sake of balance and fairness, in a follow-up article to be published next week, we’re going to take a quick look at what a handful of real scientists, clinical researchers and assorted medical experts have to say about colloidal silver and its usage.

So stay tuned, because I think you’re going to be quite surprised when you see what some of the world’s most prestigious medical, clinical and scientific experts have to say about the documented healing and infection-fighting benefits of colloidal silver!

They’ll have Dr. Joe Schwarcz in fits, to be sure!

Until the next issue, I remain…

Yours for the safe, sane and responsible use of colloidal silver,
Steve Barwick, author

Helpful Links:

Important Note and Disclaimer: The contents of this Ezine have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Information conveyed herein is from sources deemed to be accurate and reliable, but no guarantee can be made in regards to the accuracy and reliability thereof. The author, Steve Barwick, is a natural health journalist with over 30 years of experience writing professionally about natural health topics. He is not a doctor. Therefore, nothing stated in this Ezine should be construed as prescriptive in nature, nor is any part of this Ezine meant to be considered a substitute for professional medical advice. Nothing reported herein is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The author is simply reporting in journalistic fashion what he has learned during the past 17 years of journalistic research into colloidal silver and its usage. Therefore, the information and data presented should be considered for informational purposes only, and approached with caution. Readers should verify for themselves, and to their own satisfaction, from other knowledgeable sources such as their doctor, the accuracy and reliability of all reports, ideas, conclusions, comments and opinions stated herein. All important health care decisions should be made under the guidance and direction of a legitimate, knowledgeable and experienced health care professional. Readers are solely responsible for their choices. The author and publisher disclaim responsibility or liability for any loss or hardship that may be incurred as a result of the use or application of any information included in this Ezine.

Copyright 2012 | Life & Health Research Group, LLC | PO Box 1239 | Peoria AZ 85380-1239 | All rights reserved